← Research Library

Would Mashpee’s 2012 sewer options have met Waquoit Bay’s nitrogen limits? Model runs for the town’s Sewer Commission

Research Library

The short version

In 2012, Mashpee's Sewer Commission asked the Coastal Systems Program at UMass Dartmouth's School of Marine Science and Technology (SMAST) to test three wastewater options, developed with the consulting firm GHD, in the Massachusetts Estuaries Project's computer models of Popponesset Bay and Waquoit Bay. Each option treated and moved wastewater differently, all at projected full build-out. All three met the nitrogen limits throughout Popponesset Bay. In Waquoit Bay, all three met the limits for the Quashnet River and Great and Little River, but fell short of the eelgrass limits in Jehu Pond and Hamblin Pond. The authors concluded that changes on the eastern side of the watershed would not be enough on their own, and that Waquoit Bay's water quality will have to be managed by all three towns in its watershed.

What the researchers did

The team ran each option through the state's linked watershed and estuary models and compared the results with each bay's nitrogen limits.

  • All runs assumed full build-out, using a database the team built from GHD's wastewater estimates and Mashpee land use data, covering 2.7 million gallons a day of wastewater.
  • Option 1A treated about 38% of the flow to 10 mg/L and discharged it at the Rock Landing well site, outside both watersheds, sending 57% of all flow outside the watersheds.
  • Option 1B kept 87% of the flow within the watersheds, mostly treated to 3 mg/L at 11 sites, with 12% left on standard septic systems.
  • Option 1C kept 74% within the watersheds, mostly treated to 3 mg/L at 10 sites, with 18% left on septic and most flow from the Falmouth, Sandwich and Barnstable parts sent outside.
  • Only wastewater changed between runs. Nitrogen from fertilizer, runoff and the air, and the bays' inlets and depths, stayed as in the state reports.

What they found

  • Popponesset Bay meets its limits. All three options met the eelgrass limit of 0.38 mg/L at the head of Popponesset Bay and the limits for bottom-dwelling animals in the Mashpee River, Shoestring Bay and Ockway Bay. Option 1C came closest to the limits, while 1A and 1B removed more nitrogen than needed (Howes et al., 2012).
  • Jehu and Hamblin ponds fall short. In Waquoit Bay, all three options left Jehu Pond at 0.471 to 0.481 mg/L against an eelgrass limit of 0.446, and Hamblin Pond at 0.390 to 0.398 against 0.38 (Howes et al., 2012).
  • The Quashnet and Great and Little River pass. All three options met the limit for bottom-dwelling animals in the Quashnet River (about 0.50 mg/L against 0.52) and the eelgrass limit for Great and Little River (0.355 to 0.359 against 0.38) (Howes et al., 2012).
  • Little change for the Childs River. Mashpee's options cut the nitrogen load to the upper Childs River by only about 11%, and under all three the mid Childs River stayed near 0.69 mg/L against an eelgrass limit of 0.38 (Howes et al., 2012).
  • A fuller model, tougher results. Earlier 2009 runs used a model of the eastern basins alone, built on 2001–2003 data. The 2012 runs used the whole-bay model with 2002–2010 data, and the authors say that refinement likely plays a significant role in the eastern ponds now missing their limits (Howes et al., 2012).
  • A job for three towns. The authors write that the proposed changes in the eastern part of the watershed are not enough on their own to meet the limits across the system, so Waquoit Bay's water quality will have to be managed together by all three towns in the watershed (Howes et al., 2012).

What it means for Waquoit Bay today

The memo makes a point that still shapes Waquoit Bay's cleanup: Mashpee cannot restore its side of the bay alone. Even with most of the town's wastewater treated to 3 mg/L or sent out of the watershed, the models left Jehu Pond and Hamblin Pond short of their eelgrass limits. For the state limits these runs were measured against, see our summary of the first state nitrogen limits for the Quashnet, Hamblin and Jehu.

Read the memo

Howes, B., Eichner, E., Samimy, R., & Kelley, S. (2012, November 15). Scenarios results for Popponesset Bay and Waquoit Bay based on MEP linked models [Technical memorandum to the Mashpee Sewer Commission, revised]. Coastal Systems Program, School of Marine Science and Technology, University of Massachusetts Dartmouth. https://www.mashpeema.gov/DocumentCenter/View/610/Scenarios-Results-for-Popponesset-Bay-and-Waquoit-Bay-based-on-MEP-Linked-Models

License: The memo carries no license statement, so we link to the copy on the Town of Mashpee website rather than host the PDF. The card image is a title card made from the citation.

Drafted with AI assistance from the linked source.